I've been in my Masters in Social Work program for only two weeks now but I feel almost like an entirely different person. Already my professors have challenged my perceptions and have inspired me to adopt new ways of thinking. One mantra in particular has completely changed the way I approach my relationships with others, especially with people with whom I passionately disagree:
"Find the Pain."
It's magic. Let me s'plain.
Going through this program at BYU is incredibly interesting. As many already know, Brigham Young University is owned and operated by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, commonly known as the LDS or "Mormon" Church. The Church defends and upholds several values that at times conflict with emerging popular opinions. One of the most prevalent is the Church's stance on marriage: we hold to the belief that marriage is ordained of God, and that marriage between a man and a woman is central to His divine plan for the eternal destiny of His children. This has led to a clash in cultures and values between the LDS community and the LGBTQ community, especially during the time when the same-sex marriage issue was brought to the Supreme Court.
And then, there are the values embraced by the National Association of Social Workers, who operate under their own official Code of Ethics. Social Work values are simple: we work towards social justice for all individuals, with particular attention to those who are vulnerable, oppressed, or living in poverty.
Liberty, justice, and fairness for *everyone.*
In a lecture in one of my favorite classes, my professor asked a very poignant question, "How will *you* handle fairness and respect for all as an LDS social worker?"
I added this question to a list of just about a dozen other questions I have about how to live in harmony with others who have conflicting values. And I'm sure I'm not the only one who has questions about how to do this. I'm just gonna be vulnerable here and share some of my inner conflicts:
As a member of the LDS community I value the sanctity of marriage and I believe it should be kept between a man and a woman. As someone who values fairness and respect for all, I also personally believe that it's not fair to legislate my values onto a group of people who don't share the same values. I don't think it's fair for the law to prevent homosexuals to marry. I also don't think it's fair for the law to force people with strong religious beliefs to perform the marriage ceremony for homosexuals. I am passionately against discrimination toward any person of any race or sexual orientation. I don't think businesses should deny services to *anyone*. But as far as religious freedom is concerned, I don't think the government should be allowed to force people to operate against their religion (The case regarding The Little Sisters of the Poor is a good example of this).
I'm guessing I'm not the only one who struggles with this.
Being passionately anti-discrimination and passionately pro-religious freedom can be exhausting, because somehow society seems to think you have to be on one side or the other. Having passionate views from both sides of just about every issue is exhausting. And I think the reason why it's exhausting is because we live in a world where viewpoints are becoming more black and white. You either embrace all the values of the LGBTQ community or you're homophobic. You either embrace all the values of the Christian community or you're immoral and godless. If you are against police brutality, you hate cops. If you are pro-life, you are completely against a woman's right to choose. If you are pro-choice, you're okay with murder.
It's pretty easy to catch the errors in thinking, right? Then why is it so easy to fall into the "I'm right, you're wrong" trap? I know many people think that the world would be a better place if we all agreed on everything. But let's be honest. That's not happening any time soon.
I could go into how we can tackle this issue from a political perspective, but I'm more passionate about how we treat each other as human beings and how we can live harmoniously with others who do not share our values or beliefs.
Some people think they have it figured out. There are a couple mantras that are relatively popular about how we can live in harmony with others who live by different values:
1. Love the sinner, hate the sin.
2. You still love them, but . . . (fill in the blank with some phrase like, "you disagree with what they're doing" or "You don't condone their behavior.")
Can I be honest? I really don't like either of these. Let me explain why:
At a glance, these mantras may seem like they would work. But in a world that is full of black-and-white thinking, they fall apart. Because when that thinking appears, it becomes a choice to either love the sinner and the sin, or hate both. "Oh I love them, but I don't agree with what they're doing, so if I show complete and total acceptance, then I'm condoning their behavior, and I can't do that, so I need to distance myself and maybe show a little less love." In more extreme cases it becomes, "I love you, but I completely disagree with your behavior, and I cannot show that I condone it in any way, shape, or form, so I'm completely cutting you out of my life." People get ostracized from friends and family all the time for having different values and beliefs. It happens to people who switch religions. It happens to people who shun religion. It happens to people who come out and identify as LGBTQ. And it's ridiculous.
What also happens is that we tend to worry more about the "but." We focus so much on not condoning the behavior that we err on the side of judgment, rather on the side of love. The problem with "I love you, but" is that the word "but" complete negates the phrase "I love you." The problem with "Love the sinner, hate the sin" is that we're all sinners so I don't think we should go around labeling people who disagree with us as sinners. Secondly, if we cannot separate the sin and the person, that person only sees our disdain. The biases, prejudices, and stereotypes shine through. We cannot hide them. Any connection we may try to have with that person is lost.
Maybe you live by these mantras and don't have this problem. Awesome. I would just challenge you to do some personal introspection. Do you have biases against a certain group of people and/or behaviors that prevent you from connecting with certain individuals?
May I suggest a different mantra to help us connect with people with conflicting values?
Find the pain.
We are all human. We are all imperfect. And we are all broken. Somewhere, inside of all us, there is pain. Understanding pain and developing sympathy and empathy for others is how we connect.
When you come across another human being who lives a lifestyle you don't agree with, or has a completely different set of values, instead of focusing on what you think is wrong with them, find the pain. They are broken, just like you are. They don't need your condemnation. They need you. They need love, and they need connection, just like you do. And when we seek to understand each other's pain, and seek to love each other in our weaknesses, pain, and imperfections, and differences, that's when light flows into our lives and into the lives of others. That is what heals. And that is what makes the world a better place.
Connection happens when we seek to understand one another. Seeking understanding before judgment may be easier said than done, but it is choosing to take the higher road. Jesus Christ, who set the perfect example for us, chose to say, "Neither do I condemn thee" to the woman who was taken in adultery and condemned by her peers. Though she had sinned, He did not work to increase her guilt or add to the accusations. He met her where she was at, lifted her up, and encouraged her to do what was right.
I love this quote from President Kimball, a former president of the LDS Church: "Jesus saw sin as wrong but also was able to see sin as springing from deep and unmet needs on the part of the sinner. This permitted him to condemn the sin without condemning the individual."
Focus on the unmet needs. Focus on meeting the needs of others. It's far more important than being right.
Christ also taught us that the second greatest commandment is to love our neighbors. For this reason, I always find safety in erring on the side of love.
For some reason, people are afraid that withholding judgment means they're condoning immoral behavior. I personally think it doesn't. Withholding your judgment does not condone illegal or immoral behavior. Nor does it condone behavior with which you completely disagree.
In the wise words of one of my favorite professors, "It's okay to have your own values. It's not okay to condemn others for having theirs."
For me, this mantra works. This is how I want to handle fairness and respect for all as an LDS social worker. This is how I want to embrace all the values of both my religion and my job. Already I have found that it has changed the way I look at others. It has softened my gaze. It has helped me become more accepting. I'm certainly not perfect at it, but I can attest that it works.
Find the pain. Then perhaps we will finally find ourselves in a world with a little more tolerance and understanding. :)